ATF Versus Manual Gearbox Fluid: Choosing The Best Option For Your Transmission

Driver Gear, Reviews I By Bradley Iger I March 21, 2016
Along with the rigors of everyday driving, after hitting the autocross and doing a time trial event with the WR Challenger, we decided it was time to swap out the original transmission fluid for some fresh stuff, and hopefully add some extra protection in the process.
While researching what the recommended transmission fluid is for the Challenger’s Tremec TR6060 is, we came across some rather vague information about which type of fluid to use in a synchronized manual gearbox. We discovered that a large contingent of enthusiasts – and even some OEMs – recommend using automatic transmission fluid (ATF) in manual gearboxes, and that got us wondering: In general is this a wise idea? How does it affect performance and transmission longevity? Are there other considerations here?
We sat down with Chris Barker, Tech Services Manager at Royal Purple –  makers of various types of synthetic fluids for high performance applications – to get the low down.
WR: In terms of lubrication requirements, how do manual transmissions and automatics differ?
CB: The difference in lubricant function and requirements is significant.  A manual transmission is basically a box some roller bearing and bushings, two gear sets, and a couple of shafts on which the gear sets are mounted.  These components need good wear protection and rust protection.  An automatic transmission also has roller bearings and bushings, a few gear sets (this time planetary gears), and also several wet friction clutch sets.  The automatic transmission fluid must provide not only wear protection and rust protection, but also certain frictional characteristics for the clutches to operate properly and reliably transmit power as a hydraulic fluid.
WR: We’ve seen ATF recommended for use in manual gearboxes in certain applications. In general, is this a good alternative to fluid formulated specifically for manual transmissions?
CB: ATF is commonly specified for use in manual transmissions and transfer cases for 4wd and AWD vehicles.  The reason is that a light viscosity fluid is desired for less drag, and that the ATF provides the necessary wear protection and rust protection for the gears, bearings, chains and sprockets (t-cases), and clutches (t-cases) in these components.  Manual transmissions and transfer cases rarely require the extreme pressure capability of heavier GL-4 and GL-5 gear oils.
Image: Challengertalk
WR: How do lubricants like RP MAX ATF and RP Synchromax differ from one another and what would be the benefits of using Synchromax in a manual gearbox versus ATF?
CB: Max ATF and Synchromax are very similar in viscosity and base formulation.  However, the Synchromax additive package is tailored more to protecting the bearings, gears and chain and sprocket sets, with little regard to the frictional requirements of an automatic transmission clutch set.  In manual transmissions and transfer cases that specify the use of ATF or other light viscosity lubricant, Max ATF works well and is typically superior to the OEM fluid, but Synchromax is better yet than Max ATF for these components.
Although we can’t speak for its performance versus Royal Purple’s ATF offering, we can say that shifter operation in the Challenger is noticeably smoother after making the switch from the OEM fluid to Royal Purple’s Synchromax.
If you’re interested in learning more about how manual transmissions function, check out this informative video below:


The Guide to Road Racing: Winding Road Magazine's ultimate guide to getting your start in racing.

Table of Contents

Related Articles

WRR’s 5 Best Auto Racing Shoes Under $250

Here are our picks for the best auto racing shoes under $250, with a wildcard winner!

March 14, 2023
WRR’s 5 Best Auto Racing Suits Under $1,000

Racing can be very expensive, so it got us thinking; what are the best auto racing suits under $1,000?  There are plenty of high-end professional…

March 03, 2023
Review: Bell Racing RS7C LTWT Carbon Helmet

The Bell Racing RS7C LTWT Carbon is a pretty compelling helmet. It offers best in class ventilation and airflow, in addition to being one of the lightest helmets in its category.

September 20, 2022
Gear Review: The Garmin Catalyst — The Best Lap Timer?

All-in-all, we really enjoyed using and reviewing the Garmin Catalyst Driving Performance Optimizer for HPDE/track day purposes.

March 14, 2022
The Greatest Value for the Lowest Price?

The best gloves to save some money.

June 30, 2021


Get the latest driving and racing news straight to your inbox.

no thanks

Begin typing your search above and press return to search.