F1 Vs. IndyCar: Round 1

Features, Racing I By Tom Martin I May 14, 2019

F1 and IndyCar ran on the same weekend for the first time this year on May 11-12. This inspired us to comment on the relative success of each series in providing racing entertainment. Admittedly, our hypothesis is that IndyCar puts on a better show, but we're sufficiently interested in reality to want to check this out during the 2019 season.

In a nutshell, if you didn't watch both the Spanish Grand Prix and the IndyCar Grand Prix, the IndyCar event was hands-down more engaging. And honestly that assessment includes the F1 bias we bring to the table: we are avid fantasy F1 players and frankly, we just care more about F1. But, with each passing year we're increasingly wondering why.

Naturally, the problem for F1 starts with this: Lewis Hamilton essentially led all but the first 6 feet of the race. Races where someone leads pretty much flag to flag are, often, boring. Boring was the order of the day at the front of the pack in Spain because Bottas also effectively had his position (P2) for all but the first 6 feet of the race but never got close enough to challenge for the lead. Which leads us to our first substantive comment that the standing start in F1 is clearly covering up for a problem in actual competition. The best one can say, is that the standing start doesn't ruin the race. But the first lap already is plenty exciting, so the standing start, if it adds anything, adds to something that already works. "Gilding the lily", they used to say. Not a bad thing, but skepticism is in order for what follows. 

Thinking about things that happen after the first lap, how hard is it to comprehend that big aero equals small racing? Apparently harder than we think. In the event, the most exciting thing in the Spanish GP was trying to comprehend Ferrari's pit strategy, tire choices and team order decisions. We're speculating, but we're pretty sure they serve lasagna in the Ferrari pits, and they're Bolognese and thus great at cooking, so the entire team is distracted during the middle of the race. The lasagna must have been pretty darn good in Spain…

The other semi-interesting battle was Grosjean vs. Magnussen. Like Perez vs. Ocon in 2018, this one appeared to be stupidity mixed with high risk. Hard to understand. We'd whack both drivers with a wooden spoon, and apparently Gunther Steiner did.

Now look at the IndyCar Grand Prix. We've never been fans of the Indy road course, but it worked well enough. The passing point in T1 is reliable, whereas the Barcelona circuit doesn't offer much in the way of passing. That's a McDonald's vs. Burger King comparison, but better is still better.

Mediocre tracks aside, Indycar has cars that change their dynamics more during the course of a race and thus provides the opportunity for drivers to perform. Or not. In the Indy race, Felix Rosenqvist, Scott Dixon, Jack Harvey, Josef Newgarden, Patricio O'Ward and Simon Pagenaud all did interesting things that looked like attempts to lead or were actual leading. That's a lot more leadership than in the Spanish GP.

Also, the fact that the IndyCar winner (Pagenaud) led only the last 1.8 laps was exciting. Coming from 7 seconds back was thrilling. Doing all that with no push to pass, while Dixon had 15 minutes of button left, was proof that Pagenaud is still a great driver.

Yes, rain is a great equalizer — of cars. And a great differentiator — of drivers. So, perhaps, when we go to F1 vs. IndyCar: Round 2, we'll see something different. Monaco and the Indy oval certainly couldn't be more different as tracks (other than that they are both super-famous). But we're not sure the result will be.

IndyCar 1; F1: 0

The Guide to Road Racing: Winding Road Magazine's ultimate guide to getting your start in racing.

Table of Contents

Related Articles

“Porsche Outlaws” – Chronicles the Porsche hot-rodding subculture

PORSCHE OUTLAWS: STUTTGART HOT RODS, by Michael Alan Ross • Available October 1, 2024 •PREVIEW HERE: https://bit.ly/PorscheOutlaws  Get an inside look at the irreverent, rule-breaking…

August 09, 2024
Ultra Rare 1957 Ferrari 625 TRC Spider to Be Auctioned at Monterey Car Week

Widely considered one of the most beautiful body designs ever created, this impressive 1957 Ferrari 625 TRC Spider will be offered on Saturday night at…

July 22, 2024
Iconic 1934 Alfa Romeo 8C 2300 Lungo Spider with Original Coachwork Heads to Auction

Boasting long-term ownership and meticulous maintenance, this 8C is a highly respected, very pure example of the legendary “2.3” and will cross the block in…

July 18, 2024
Super 3 Origins: Celebrating Super 3 Inspirations with Nine Limited-Edition Commissions

Morgan is celebrating the original inspirations for its rebellious Super 3 with a limited-edition series of commissions known as Super 3 Origins. The collection features…

July 10, 2024
The Bugatti Tourbillon: An Automotive Icon ‘Pour L’éternité’

Molsheim, France, 21 June 2024 – In 2004, the reborn Bugatti brand transformed the world of automotive performance and luxury with a 1,001 hp hyper…

June 21, 2024

EMAIL SIGN UP

Get the latest driving and racing news straight to your inbox.

no thanks

Begin typing your search above and press return to search.